For years, the NFL has relied on the tried-and-true coin toss to determine possession at the start of the game and overtime. But let’s be honest—flipping a coin is about as exciting as watching paint dry while eating unsalted crackers. It’s time for a change, and what better way to add some flair to the game than by introducing the ultimate test of psychological warfare: Rock, Paper, Scissors (RPS)?

The Coin Toss Is Boring, Let’s Admit It

The coin toss has been around since the dawn of sports, but does anyone really find it entertaining? The referee dramatically holds up the coin, calls are made, it spins in the air, and… that’s it. The entire event is over in less time than it takes to microwave a Hot Pocket. There’s no strategy, no skill—just pure dumb luck.

More importantly, coin tosses can have a huge impact on the game. Take overtime, for example. Winning the coin toss can be the difference between victory and defeat, especially in the playoffs. And while life isn’t fair, sports should at least pretend to be. By replacing the coin toss with RPS, we’d be injecting an element of strategy into the decision-making process. Plus, it would make for some electric television.

Rock, Paper, Scissors: The High-Stakes Psychological Showdown

Unlike a coin toss, Rock, Paper, Scissors is an actual battle of wits. It’s a mind game where players must read their opponent, anticipate their move, and execute the perfect counter. You think Patrick Mahomes isn’t going to study RPS strategy like it’s the Super Bowl playbook? You better believe he will.

Imagine this: Instead of two captains standing around watching a piece of metal spin, they stare each other down, hands ready, sweat dripping, while the stadium holds its collective breath. The ref yells, “Rock, Paper, Scissors… SHOOT!” and boom—chaos ensues. One team’s fans erupt in celebration, while the other experiences immediate heartbreak. It’s everything sports should be.

And let’s talk about the potential for controversy! Did the opposing captain throw late? Was that a questionable paper formation? Should the NFL introduce an RPS review system? The drama writes itself.

How It Would Revolutionize the NFL (and Make Bookies Sweat)

Sports fans love controversy and unpredictability. With RPS in place, teams could scout their opponents’ tendencies, hire specialized Rock, Paper, Scissors coaches, and even analyze film on past decisions. Suddenly, the opening possession isn’t just about luck—it’s about preparation, confidence, and elite-level hand placement.

Of course, with any change in sports, the gambling world would take notice. You think Vegas wouldn’t set odds on whether a team captain will throw rock or scissors? This could be the biggest thing to happen to sports betting since the invention of the parlay. Speaking of betting, fans often wonder, is sports betting legal in Florida? The answer changes often, so it’s always best to check local laws before wagering your hard-earned cash on whether a team captain will panic and throw rock three times in a row.

Final Thoughts: Let’s Make This Happen

The NFL prides itself on innovation. We’ve got microchipped footballs, new rules every season, and a constant drive to make the game better. So why not upgrade one of the most outdated parts of the sport? Rock, Paper, Scissors is fast, strategic, and—most importantly—way more entertaining than a 50/50 coin flip.

It’s time for the league to embrace change and give us the high-stakes, heart-pounding, utterly ridiculous drama we deserve. The fans are ready. The players are ready. And somewhere, a coach is already diagramming the perfect Rock, Paper, Scissors strategy on a whiteboard. Let’s make this happen, NFL.

Related

Resources